So many fan theories, so little time! In the long, cold winter between Game of Thrones seasons, fans of A Song of Ice and Fire are left with little choice but to spend their time solving the most nagging of mysteries within the show. They have no choice! And sometimes, those theories just make too much gosh darn sense. The inner conspiracy theorist inside of all of us is really clinging to a new theory put forth by reddit user Ghostchief that suggests Jon Snow may have another sibling to add to his already large and complicated family.

Join Jessica Chobot on today’s Nerdist News as we put everything we know about Jon Snow and his lineage up on one of those cork boards and connect all the details with little pieces of red yarn like we’re the coolest but most misunderstood detectives in the office (Fox Mulder eat your heart out).

Thanks for watching today’s episode! Don’t miss Dan Casey talking about a J.K. Rowling-approved fan-theory from the Harry Potter universe on this week’s Dan Cave, and let us know in the comments if you think this prediction is likely to come true in the upcoming sixth season of Game of Thrones.