close menu

AMERICAN HORROR STORY Recap: This Is Halloween

Last night American Horror Story aired Part II of their “Edward Mordrake” episode, filling in a lot of character backstory and wrapping up a few story lines in the process.

The episode began essentially where last week left off, with Mordrake getting the freaks accounts of how they became who they are today, each story more tragic than the last. Eventually Mordrake comes for Elsa and we understand how she lost her legs. A casualty of one of the first German snuff films, Elsa was bound to a bed and they were sawed off by a chainsaw all happening as the cameras rolled. When she finished her tale, devastated by reliving the account, she begged Mordrake to take her, essentially putting her out of her misery. Instead, he found his way to Twisty the Clown, forcing him to tell his tale.

Meanwhile, Jimmy Darling and Esmerelda still find themselves stranded on the road and with curfew still in effect, not many cars pass them by. Suddenly, one of the children held captive by Twisty bursts from the woods only to be reclaimed by Twisty and taken back to his school bus. Jimmy follows them back to try and help and Esmerelda follows. They are both captured by Dandy and Esmerelda awakes to find herself about to be sawn in half. Jimmy is able to break free from his ties and hit Dandy and free Esmerelda as she and the kids run to the road to find help. Jimmy watches from afar as Twisty is visited by the ghost of Edward Mordrake.

AHS Edward Mordrake main

When series like American Horror Story book major actors for an arch on the show, you have to assume that it’s going to be worth it for the talent involved. Regarding AHS, I know that I’ve found myself telling friends, “You don’t hire John Carroll Lynch to hide his face behind a mask and be without speech for the entire run of the show. It just doesn’t make sense.” Last night, through flashback, we saw how Twisty the Clown began and how he became the monster we’ve come to know throughout the first four episodes of Freak Show. Born to an alcoholic mother and neglected as a child, Lynch’s tragic clown found himself slightly developmentally disabled and working on the carnival circuit. When rumors of child molestation began to swirl (we don’t ever find out if they’re true, either) he is run off by the others in his show. He reveals to Mordrake that word traveled fast that he was a child abuser and no one would hire him. He attempted to refashion old junk as toys and sell them to the local toy shop (the owner of which met a grisly end earlier this season) but when he was refused, he became aggressive and became isolated and ostracized. Twisty tried to take his own life with a shotgun but, unfortunately for him, he only succeeded in blowing his jaw off. Mordrake’s evil appendage decides that Twisty is the one and Mordrake puts him out of his misery. Twisty’s soul joins the rest of the dead freaks and returns to hell. Jimmy departs just before Dandy wakes up to find Twisty dead but not before taking his mask and returning home to actually kill Patti LaBelle’s Dora the maid.

Because of Mordrake killing Twisty, Jimmy is looked on as a hero, saving the children who had been held captive. The next morning while talking to the police, Esmerelda confirms that Jimmy saved the day and she seems to be growing a sincere affection for him. Meanwhile, Jimmy hasn’t forgotten the unjust murder of Meep and lets the detective who is interviewing him and who is responsible for his friends death know it. When Esmerelda and Jimmy return to the tents, a group of locals arrive almost simultaneously. Esmerelda braces herself to be evicted but instead, it is the parents of the children who were set free, coming to thank Jimmy for what he has done. They all mingle with the freaks, greet them with treats, shake hands and purchase tickets to that evenings show.

The episode ended with Dennis O’Hare’s Stanley (or, “Richard” for now) finding his way to the Freak Show in Jupiter to join Esmerelda in potentially killing one of the freaks to sell them to the museum. He is posing as a Hollywood agent which is irresistible to Elsa. The tease for next week promises that the peace that fell over the Freak Show towards the end of the episode won’t last long.

I’m loving this season of American Horror Story, which feels just as dangerous and gruesome as past seasons but with a lot of the heart and character drama of Murder House. We’re only a third of the way through the season, so there’s still a lot more story to go. This week we didn’t see much from Dot and Bette, from Del or Desiree or from Ethel, stories that have mostly taken center stage so far this season. There is surely a lot more to come from them as well as from Francis Conroy’s Gloria Mott and her dealings with her very naughty son Dandy.

One more thing to note is that now that Twisty the Clown, who is been referred to as the seasons “Big Bad,” is dead and assuming that we’ve seen the last of him this season, are we to assume that Dandy is filling the shoes of Twisty or does American Horror Story have something else in store for us? Stay tuned!

American Horror Story: Freak Show airs Wednesdays at 10PM on FX.

Images: FX

Giraffes Barely Sleep, and When They do, it's on Their Butts

Giraffes Barely Sleep, and When They do, it's on Their Butts

Schlock & Awe: Chuck Norris in INVASION U.S.A.

Schlock & Awe: Chuck Norris in INVASION U.S.A.


Was THE SIMPSONS' "Homer at the Bat" Lineup Really That Good?



  1. Carrie says:

    I thought it was interesting that although Twisty’s clown outfit made me think of John Wayne Gacy, he was much more like Ed Gein when we got to know him–attached to his mother, mentally slow, and unable to function normally on his own. I confess that I felt a certain sympathy for him once I heard his story. In the end, I find Dandy much more frightening because he is brutal and murderous (IMHO) because he enjoys it, just for the pleasure of it. 

  2. I TOTALLY disagree with the the following: When rumors of child molestation began to swirl (we don’t ever find out if they’re true, either). The two men watching in the previous scene STATED that they wanted to get rid of him because THEY wanted the children to squirm on their laps and that the clown didn’t appreciate it!  They then scared him off in the fire scene.  This was VERY obvious to me and I would think to any watcher of the show.

  3. kerrell says:

    I’m not gonna lie,I was bummed they did away with twisty four episodes in. But John Carrol Lynch was undeniably amazing for those episodes,definitely an unforgettable performance. With that being said I’m still really enjoying this season and after seeing the teaser for next week it looks like there’s still plenty of shock and horror for us AHS fans.

    • G says:

      I agree about Twisty’s early demise. They had a good thing going with him and offing him so soon takes some of the thrill out of this season’s remaining episodes. The new Twisty should be interesting, but just not as spooky since we know who it is parading around in the mask. 
      Also, didn’t like the way Twisty’s origin was revealed this episode. Again, it takes away the mystery and suspense factor. I was really digging this season up until episode 4. Hoping it’s not a sign of things to come.

      • Zach says:

        I agree to a degree about Twisty’s demise. I loved the character. I loved the brutality behind him. Really bringing fear. But what he was looking for through all 4 eps was a sense of belonging. It wasn’t readily apparent in prior episodes when he wasn’t able to speak but it was there. In episode 1 he watched the freaks from the bushes while they killed the detective. Was he “stalking” them? Or was he looking for acceptance into that group, longing to be a part? (We see now that it was the latter because in his flashbacks he was outside the big top trying to give away balloon animals). Another example was his captured “family”. Was he torturing them? Or was he trying to give them what they were lacking, while giving himself the family he wanted? (Again, the latter because that’s essentially what he said)
        While it’s sad to see him go. It’s also a beautiful ending to his character. He finally found his acceptance. His family. Edward Mordrake and his other victims. We see this as they depart together. 
        I’m also intrigued by Dandy’s (is it really Dandy? I always assumed it was Danny, my ears must have tricked me) stepping into Twisty’s oversized clown shoes. Him putting the mask on was a passing of the torch, per say. It gave Dandy the courage/strength/power to actually go through with killing Dora. I also feel they could make Dandy a much more “scary” killer because his is of complete hate and malice compared to Twisty’s hate and frustration of not being accepted. 
        Sorry for the wall of text. But I thought it was a great ending to Twisty’s story (and real beginning of Dandy’s) after I got over the gut-punch of losing the great symbol of fear that Twisty has brought to many of us up to this point. 
        Is it Wednesday yet?

        • danielle says:

          if you watch i believe the 3rd episode where dandy meets twists you’ll see on his glass baby bottle he drinks whistkey out of says “dandy” =)   i’m really disaapointed they did away with twisty so early…they better bring on the fear factor because so far its a little lackluster in comparison to season 1 or 2.   i need it darker. 

        • T says:

          Well said Zach, plus just because an interesting character died, doesn’t mean there is nothing left! You haven’t seen what’s coming yet.