A show like Sleepy Hollow seems tailor made for the Comic-Con crowd. A fan favorite in every sense, during its freshman season the series managed to blend horror, action and humor and easily became one of the biggest new shows of the 2013-14 television season.

This year at Comic Con International in San Diego, Nerdist spoke with show runner Mark Goffman and co-creator Alex Kurtzman as well as Ichabod Crane and Abbie Mills themselves, Tom Mison and Nicole Beharie, about what fans can expect from the upcoming season, including scoops on Benjamin Franklin and what to look forward to from an expanded season two.

Sleepy Hollow returns for season two on Monday, September 22 on Fox.