Whether it’s in the comics or the AMC TV show, Jesse Custer, a.k.a. Preacher, uses his fantastic abilities to (most of the time) take down evil in all shapes and forms. From demons to cults to his own screwed-up family, he has gone against the toughest of opponents. Who could have guessed that one of his greatest trials would be a wrestling match against fun-loving talk show host James Corden?

The Late Late Show’s YouTube channel posted this video of James teaming up with Preacher executive producer Seth Rogen to deliver pizzas to random homes around Los Angeles. The unsuspecting (but pleasantly surprised) customers were given a choice: take the pizza they ordered, or choose the “mystery pizza box” James and Seth brought with them. Of course, everyone chose the mystery box, and prizes included a box of tomato sauce, an “Instagram Party,” and a chance to watch James Corden wrestle the star of Preacher, Dominic Cooper.

It looked like a hard fought battle (either that or clever editing), but eventually, Dominic was able to force James to tap out. I couldn’t really tell if it was from pain or utter exhaustion. Regardless of the winner, when the night starts off with a wrestling match and ends like this…

…there really are no losers, right?

You can check out more hilarity from James Corden on his YouTube channel here.

Who else from late night would you like to see Dominic take down? Let me know on Twitter or sound off in the comments below.

Images: The Late Late Show with James Corden/YouTube