It’s been two weeks since the Suicide Squad teaser trailer from Comic-Con was released, and we still can’t stop thinking about it. There are so many details offered, so much information to unpack, and so many theories about Harley Quinn and the gang to cook up! One fan theory in particular has been popping up over and over again: Is the gaunt, tattooed Joker that we see in the David Ayer film really the Joker we know and love, or could he be someone else from Batman‘s past? The theory boldly suggests he may be Jason Todd, the second boy wonder.

Join Jessica Chobot as we break down this fan theory and explain why we aren’t so quick to jump on board the Robin-train, on today’s Nerdist News!

Thanks for watching today’s show, be sure to check out our report on Universal’s upcoming video game-centric theme park, let us know in the comments if you think this fan theory is probable or impossible, and don’t miss our take on what everyone was expecting to see from Suicide Squad: