Given that we were at Disney’s D23 Expo, it didn’t seem right to only ask the assembled cast and filmmakers about their upcoming projects. We were at a Disney fan convention, and I wanted them to dig a little bit deeper into their personal Disney fandom, so I asked everyone from Kristen Bell to Tom Hiddleston to Christina Hendricks to tell me their earliest Disney memory. Why the earliest instead of their favorite? When you take a walk down memory lane like that and really try to figure out what was the exact moment that hooked you, you wind up with some really great stuff.

For even more awesome content including our behind-the-scenes D23 and Marvel interviews, visit the Nerdist Channel. What is your earliest Disney memory? Or, fine, what is your favorite Disney memory? Let us know in the comments below!