Listen, you guys, saving the world day in and day out from all manner of supervillains, otherworldly monsters, and apocalyptic cosmic threats is pretty exhausting and leaves little time for romance. So, naturally, you can imagine that the Justice League would be reluctant to embrace the spirit of Valentine’s Day — it’s not exactly in their wheelhouse, after all. Fortunately someone was there to stoke the flames of romance a little bit. No, not Cupid; He was busy. This year, the part of matchmaker was played by everyone’s favorite backwards-talkin’ magician Zatanna, and her arrows of love were a batch of enchanted sugar cookies. What happens next? Well, you need to see for yourself.

You’ve already spent Thanksgiving and Christmas with your favorite gang of highly (dys)functional superheroes, so why not cuddle up with your loved one and spend Valentine’s Day with them too? Trust us — you’re going to love it.

What’s your favorite superhero couple? What other holidays would you like to see the Justice League celebrate? Let us know in the comments below, and be sure to subscribe to the Nerdist Channel for even more superheroic goodness.